Fresh from our kitchen to yours, with a love for family & food
A Family Tradition, Crafted with Passion
Sutton's Family Italian is a Lexington tradition, proudly serving the community for over 14 years. We are a family-owned and operated restaurant, carrying on a long-held Italian tradition of love, shared meals, and delicious food.
Our story starts in Italy, where the Mastarone family fostered a deep-seated passion for cooking and sharing authentic Italian dishes. This legacy was passed down through generations, leading to the creation of Sutton's. With over 26 years of experience in the industry, our chef and owner, Gordon Lewis, brings a wealth of expertise and creativity to our kitchen.
Taste the Difference
At Sutton's, we celebrate fresh, seasonal ingredients and traditional recipes to craft your culinary experience. From classic Italian favorites like authentic pasta dishes and savory meatballs to creative seafood creations, our menu offers something for every palate.
More than just a Meal
Sutton's is not just about serving exceptional food. We are dedicated to creating a welcoming and warm atmosphere where guests can truly enjoy the Italian dining experience. Our friendly staff will guide you through our menu and wine selections, ensuring a memorable evening.
Catering with Care
Beyond our restaurant, Sutton's offers exceptional catering services for any occasion. We cater weddings, birthday parties, corporate events, and everything in between. Our extensive menu options and personalized approach ensure that your event is a culinary success.
Our Services
- Fine Dining Experience: Enjoy a traditional Italian meal in our cozy and inviting atmosphere.
- Custom Catering Solutions: Plan your next event with our diverse catering menu and personalized attention.
- Family Feasting: Delight in our family-style Sunday dinners, offering a classic Italian dining experience for the whole family.
- Private Dining Experience: Host a memorable gathering in our dedicated private dining room.
Overall Experience
Reviews highlight the excellent service, delicious food, and welcoming atmosphere at Sutton's. Many reviewers praised their servers, mentioning their courteous and attentive service. The food quality was consistently high, with popular dishes like Chicken Parmesan, Chicken Marsala, and eggplant Parmesan receiving rave reviews.
Food Quality and Variety
The menu offers a range of options, with reviewers enjoying the flavorful sauces, fresh ingredients, and generous portions. The Chicken Parmesan and marinara sauce, in particular, were praised as some of the best.
Service and Staff
Servers were consistently praised for their attentiveness, friendliness, and helpfulness. Reviewers appreciated the personalized service, with some mentioning the manager's presence and welcoming nature.
Atmosphere and Ambiance
The atmosphere was described as welcoming, with some reviewers enjoying the patio area. However, one reviewer mentioned the bright lights in the bar area as a drawback.
Criticisms and Areas for Improvement
Some reviewers mentioned minor issues, such as understaffing, sauce quantities, and a lack of background music. However, one reviewer had a poor experience on Valentine's Day, citing long wait times, mistakes with orders, and a lack of management presence.
Be the first to review Sutton's.
Write a Review
