Website Call now
Website
Call

Choose local. Choose independent. Choose Stacy Insurance Agency.

Stacy Insurance Agency has proudly served the Findlay community and beyond since 1955. As a local, independent insurance agency, we prioritize personalized service and a commitment to finding you the best coverage at competitive rates.

Our Expertise

Our team of experienced agents understands the unique insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in the area. We are experts in:

  • Auto Insurance: Find the perfect plan for your vehicle, whether it's a daily driver or a classic car.
  • Home Insurance: Protect your most valuable asset with customized coverage options.
  • Business Insurance: Get tailored protection for your company, regardless of its size or industry.
  • Life Insurance: Secure your family's future with various plans to choose from.
  • And More: We also offer coverage for motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles, and more.

The Benefits of Working with an Independent Agent

Choosing an independent insurance agency like Stacy Insurance Agency comes with several advantages:

  • Choice: We work with multiple trusted insurance carriers, giving you access to a wider range of policies and competitive rates.
  • Independence: We are not tied to any single carrier, allowing us to find the best coverage for your unique needs.
  • Personalized Service: We take the time to understand your individual situation and provide tailored insurance recommendations.
  • Local Expertise: Our agents are familiar with the local market and understand the specific needs of the Findlay community.

Get a Free Quote Today

Requesting a quote from Stacy Insurance Agency is easy and obligation-free. Simply contact us through our website or call us at 419-422-0544 to discuss your insurance needs and receive a personalized quote. We look forward to helping you find the protection you need at a price you can afford!

Reviews (17)
Write a Review
Positive: The positive comments seem to focus on the agency's convenient location and excellent customer service.
Negative: The negative comments highlight concerns about the agency's trustworthiness and customer service.

Location Convenience

Stacy Insurance seems to have a convenient location, according to Michael Gorman, who mentioned that the agency is right across the street from the University of Findlay, making it easily accessible.

Customer Service and Coverage

Many reviewers have had positive experiences with the agency's customer service and coverage. Reviewers like Josh Zachman, Edie D., Jackelyn Lee, Julie Woods, and Elizabeth Julius have praised Dave Erickson, the agent, for being knowledgeable, professional, and helpful. They have also mentioned that he finds the right policy for clients and provides excellent service.

Comparison to Other Options

Some reviewers have compared Stacy Insurance to other options. Judy Burlile Brown, for example, switched to another provider after being hit by an uninsured driver. She mentioned getting better coverage at a lower cost from another provider.

Concerns about the Agency

One reviewer, Greg Davidson, had a negative experience with the agency, calling it a "complete scam" and stating that he will never go back to it or recommend it to anyone.