Mitchell Insurance Agency

At Mitchell Insurance Agency of Oshkosh, we are dedicated to providing our clients with exceptional insurance services that cater to their unique needs. As a family-owned and operated, independent insurance agency, we take pride in offering personalized attention and customized solutions to ensure our clients receive the best possible coverage at competitive rates. With over 30 companies to choose from, we have the flexibility to tailor our services to fit each individual's specific requirements.

Our Story

Our agency was founded by Jim Mitchell, who has been in the insurance industry for over 38 years. Jim's mission was to create an agency that would offer the small-town, neighborly service and care that the people in our community desire and deserve. By establishing our own independent agency, we have been able to provide our clients with a wide range of choices and options, while ensuring they receive the best possible price.

Our Services

We offer a comprehensive range of insurance services, including Auto, Home, Business, Commercial, Renters, Recreational, SR-22's, Life, and Senior Products. Our team of experienced and dedicated professionals is committed to taking the hassle out of buying and managing insurance. We understand that every client is unique, and we take the time to listen to their needs and concerns, providing them with personalized solutions that meet their specific requirements.

Our Mission

At Mitchell Insurance Agency of Oshkosh, our mission is to build long-term relationships with our clients, providing them with exceptional service and care. We believe in taking the time to get to know our clients, understanding their needs, and tailoring our services to fit their individual requirements. We are committed to being a trusted advisor, providing our clients with the knowledge and expertise they need to make informed decisions about their insurance needs.

Our Awards and Recognition

We are proud to have been voted as the Best Insurance Agency in Winnebago County for ten years running. Jim Mitchell has also been voted as the Best Insurance Agent in Winnebago County and Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in 2022 and 2023. Additionally, we were voted as a Finalist in the Best Insurance Agency in Milwaukee Journal Sentinel in 2022 and 2023. We are incredibly appreciative of our clients for allowing us to be recognized for our commitment to exceptional service and care.