Garnsey Brothers Insurance, a trusted local agency in Sanford, Maine, has been guiding clients towards reliable and affordable insurance coverage since 1947. As an independent agency, we work for you, not a specific insurance company. This allows us to provide unbiased, personalized advice and find the best possible coverage options from a wide range of trusted partners.
Who We Are
Our team of experienced insurance professionals is dedicated to understanding your unique needs and tailoring insurance solutions that meet your specific requirements. We believe in building lasting relationships with our clients and providing personalized attention every step of the way. We are passionate about empowering you to make informed insurance decisions and feel confident that you're adequately protected.
What We Do
We offer a comprehensive range of insurance products to protect you and your loved ones, regardless of your individual needs. Our services include:
- Auto Insurance: Comprehensive coverage for your car, motorcycle, boat, or other vehicles.
- Home Insurance: Protection for your home against unexpected events like fire, theft, or natural disasters.
- Business Insurance: Customized coverage tailored to your specific business needs, including general liability, property, and workers' compensation.
- Life Insurance: Secure your loved ones financially in the event of your passing.
Why Choose an Independent Agent?
Working with an independent agent like Garnsey Brothers Insurance offers you several advantages:
- Choice: We partner with multiple insurance companies, allowing us to compare plans and find the best coverage at competitive prices.
- Personalized Attention: We take the time to understand your unique needs and risk factors to recommend the right insurance solutions.
- Advocacy: We work on your behalf to handle claims and ensure you get the compensation you deserve.
- Local Expertise: As part of the community, we have a deep understanding of the local risks and challenges in the Sanford area.
Contact Us Today
Protect what matters most and get the peace of mind you deserve by requesting a free quote from Garnsey Brothers Insurance today. We are committed to providing you with exceptional service, tailored coverage, and comprehensive protection for every stage of life.
Insurance Agents' Performance
Exceptional Service and Expertise
The majority of reviewers praised their insurance agents, particularly Christopher Signore, for their exceptional service, expertise, and dedication to finding the best rates and solutions for their clients.
Trusted Advisors
Many reviewers appreciated their agents' willingness to go above and beyond to answer questions, explain complex policies, and provide personalized advice. They felt confident in their agents' abilities to navigate the insurance process and trusted them to make recommendations that met their needs.
Prompt and Effective Communication
Reviewers also highlighted the agents' prompt responses to inquiries, emails, and messages, even outside of regular business hours. This demonstrated a high level of commitment to customer satisfaction and a willingness to accommodate their clients' schedules.
Negative Experiences
Disappointment with Plan Changes and Lack of Communication
A few reviewers expressed disappointment with changes to their insurance plans, which were made without their knowledge or consent. They felt that the agents or companies did not take responsibility for the changes and did not provide adequate explanations or solutions.
Dropped Coverage and Increased Premiums
Some reviewers experienced unexpected increases in their premiums or were dropped by their insurance providers without adequate notice or support from their agents.

Be the first to review Garnsey Brothers Insurance.
Write a Review