Insurance That Works For You
At McCutcheon Insurance Agency, Inc., we are dedicated to providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals and businesses across Ohio. With over 70 years of experience, our independent insurance agency has been serving the communities of Akron, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton, and Toledo with expertise and compassion.
Our History
Founded in 1947 in Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, our agency has a rich history of providing comprehensive insurance options to our clients. In 2014, we merged with The Buffington Agency and relocated to our current address in Akron, expanding our range of services and expertise. Our team of certified insurance professionals, led by Jenny Pillen, C.I.C. and Jennifer Keim, C.I.C., is committed to delivering exceptional service and guidance to our clients.
Our Services
We offer a wide range of insurance products and services, including auto, homeowners, business, and motorcycle insurance. Our team of experts takes the time to understand the unique needs of each client, providing personalized solutions that fit their specific situation. We work with multiple insurance providers to ensure that our clients receive the best possible coverage at competitive rates.
Auto Insurance
We are Ohio auto insurance specialists, dedicated to finding the best coverage for our clients. Our team shops various auto insurance partners to provide the most competitive rates and comprehensive coverage. From liability protection to collision coverage, we design policies that meet the unique needs of each client.
Homeowners Insurance
At McCutcheon Insurance Agency, we understand the importance of protecting your home and property. Our homeowners insurance policies are designed to provide comprehensive coverage for your dwelling, personal belongings, and liability. We work with multiple insurance providers to secure the best possible rates and coverage for our clients.
Business Insurance
As a business owner, you face unique risks and challenges. Our team of experts works closely with clients to understand their commercial requirements, identifying exposed risks and creating a plan to manage those risks. We offer business insurance solutions that protect your business, employees, and assets, giving you peace of mind and confidence in your business operations.
Why Choose Us
At McCutcheon Insurance Agency, we pride ourselves on our personalized service, expertise, and commitment to our clients. Our team of certified insurance professionals is dedicated to providing exceptional guidance and support, ensuring that our clients receive the best possible coverage and service. We are an independent Ohio insurance agency, serving the communities of Akron, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton, and Toledo with integrity and compassion.
Overview
McCutcheon Insurance has received overwhelmingly positive reviews from its clients. The reviewers praised the agency's exceptional service, knowledgeable and helpful staff, and ability to provide personalized assistance.
Positive Reviews
The majority of reviewers rated McCutcheon Insurance 5 stars, praising the agency's commitment to providing excellent customer service. Many reviewers appreciated the personalized attention they received from the staff, particularly Jennifer Keim, who was repeatedly mentioned for her exceptional service. Reviewers praised the agency's ability to find the best insurance rates, provide timely responses to questions and concerns, and provide guidance throughout the insurance process.
Negative Review
The only negative review came from Dan Golias, who rated the agency 1 star. He expressed disappointment with the agency's response to his concerns, citing a lack of communication and resolution. He also mentioned that the agency failed to provide adequate support during a claim, leading him to explore other insurance options.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f63d1/f63d1df81f278914db333ecc327c6399823705b4" alt="Review Mccutcheon Insurance Agency"
Be the first to review Mccutcheon Insurance Agency.
Write a Review