Simplifying Freight Shipping, So You Can Focus on Your Business.
Welcome to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria - where New York meets the Southwest!
My Slice of the Pie is a family-owned and operated pizzeria in Arcadia, proudly serving up delicious New York-style pizza infused with a touch of Southwestern flair. We've become known for our fresh, flavorful dishes, exceptional customer service, and lightning-fast delivery.
What Sets Us Apart
Our pizzas are crafted with top-notch ingredients and a passion for deliciousness. We use only the freshest toppings and traditional New York dough, ensuring each bite is a delightful combination of flavors and textures. Our menu also features a variety of other delectable offerings, including salads, pastas, and delicious appetizers.
Our Pizza Perfection
Our signature pizzas blend the best of both worlds. Enjoy classic flavors like The Supreme Being with its gourmet toppings or delight in the unique El Rey pizza with its combination of succulent pollo asado and savory chorizo. We also offer vegan and vegetarian options, ensuring something for everyone.
Beyond Pizza
Looking for something beyond pizza? We have you covered! Our salads are fresh and made with seasonal ingredients, while our pastas are cooked with our own delicious marinara. We also have tempting appetizers like wings and flavorful dips, perfect for sharing or enjoying on your own.
Fresh, Fast, and Flavorful
At My Slice of the Pie, we believe in fresh ingredients, fast service, and outstanding flavor. Our dedicated team works with meticulous care to ensure your food is prepared to perfection and delivered promptly. We strive to provide an exceptional dining experience with every order.
Experience the My Slice of the Pie Difference!
Whether you're craving a classic NY-style pizza or want to try something new, My Slice of the Pie is your go-to pizza shop in Arcadia. Order online or give us a call and let us delight your taste buds with a delicious slice of New York meets the Southwest!
Overview of Reviews
The reviews of My Slice of the Pie are predominantly positive, with customers praising the pizza, wings, and atmosphere of the restaurant.
Food Quality
Most reviewers raved about the pizza, citing it as one of the best they've had in the Phoenix and Scottsdale area, with some even comparing it to New York-style pizza. The Al Pastor pizza and wings were particularly popular, with many recommending them. However, a few reviewers had negative experiences with the food, mentioning that the spaghetti was horrible and the garlic toast was dry.
Service and Atmosphere
The service was generally praised, with many reviewers mentioning that the staff was friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was also commended, with some describing it as laid-back and others appreciating the unique interior design.
Recommendations
Many reviewers recommended specific dishes, including the Cheese Pizza, Al Pastor pizza, wings, and cheesecake. Some also mentioned that the restaurant is a hidden gem, worth trying for its unique fusion of Mexican and Italian flavors.
Be the first to review My Slice Of The Pie Pizzeria.
Write a Review
