Connect with Top-Rated Insurance Agents in Sarasota!

Read verified customer reviews of the most reliable insurance agents in Sarasota, FL. Save time and money by comparing prices, getting expert recommendations, and finding the perfect fit for your needs.

Find businesses near you
The Warren Middleton State Farm Insurance office is proud to serve Sarasota, Lakewood, and Bradenton, FL with Insurance and Financial Services, with a focus on resident relocations to the Sarasota County area. Our team of licensed Insurance Professionals are here to help get you Insurance coverage for your specific needs. Not only can we help with Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Renters Insurance, Life Insurance and Financial Services, but we are also able to assist small business owners with their Commercial lines of Insurance.
The reviewers praised the exceptional customer service, knowledge, and responsiveness of the agents at Warren Middleton Insurance Agency.
5.0
Based on 315 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Morgan Insurance is a trusted insurance agency in Sarasota, Florida, offering a comprehensive range of insurance products and services, including auto, home, flood, condo, boat, motorcycle, golf cart, long-term care, renters, umbrella, life, and commercial auto insurance. Our team of experts provides personalized insurance solutions, exceptional customer service, and professional advice to individuals and families in Sarasota and surrounding areas.
The reviews praise the agency for their exceptional customer service, professionalism, and personalized attention.
5.0
Based on 119 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The Peeples Insurance Agency is a leading provider of personal and commercial insurance solutions tailored to suit the unique needs of our clients. With offices in Sarasota, Bradenton, and Margate, we serve all of Florida, providing superior service and protection for individuals, families, and businesses across the state.
The majority of customers have reported extremely positive experiences with Peeples Insurance, praising the agency's exceptional customer service, professionalism, and expertise.
A few customers have reported some issues with communication and follow-up, including difficulties in getting quotes, unreturned calls, and canceled policies without notice.
4.8
Based on 238 reviews
Profile Website Phone
At West Florida Insurance Agency, we pride ourselves on offering money saving solutions that meet the needs of our clients. We work with secure insurance carriers to provide comprehensive insurance packages and unwavering support. We offer a range of insurance services including Health Insurance, Auto Insurance, Property Insurance, Business Insurance, and Life Insurance. Our goal is to provide quality insurance with sufficient coverage at an affordable price. With over 12 states licensed and an extensive knowledge of Florida insurance, we are a trusted name in the insurance industry. We are committed to providing exceptional service and ensuring that our clients receive the best insurance coverage for their needs.
The agency has received many positive reviews, praising their customer service, insurance services, and professionalism.
Some reviewers have had negative experiences with the agency's customer service, citing unprofessional, rude, and poor service.
4.7
Based on 26 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Jason Flatch State Farm Insurance is a local insurance agency in Sarasota, FL, offering a range of insurance products, including Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Life, Health, Pet, and Business Insurance, as well as financial services and banking products. With over 80 years of combined experience, our team provides personalized insurance solutions and exceptional customer service to our good neighbors in Sarasota, Venice, Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, Siesta Key, and Longboat Key.
Customers praise the agency's professionalism, friendliness, and helpfulness.
A few customers had issues with communication and refunds.
4.6
Based on 110 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Coffey Insurance Agency Inc is a full-service insurance agency offering a wide range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, and health insurance. With over 35 years of experience, our team is dedicated to providing personalized service and tailored insurance solutions to individuals and businesses in Sarasota and Manatee counties. We are proud to be a preferred local insurance agent and a strong supporter of local charitable organizations and youth and area schools.
The reviews praise the exceptional customer service, prompt and personalized attention, knowledgeable staff, and instances of going above and beyond to help customers.
4.6
Based on 86 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Leslie Jeffrey Insurance Agency is a State Farm Insurance Agent providing auto, homeowners, renters, life, and business insurance products to individuals and businesses in Sarasota, FL. Our mission is to help you create a Personal Price Plan that fits your unique needs and priorities.
The majority of reviewers praised the agency's helpful and friendly staff, efficient service, and thoroughness in answering questions and processing paperwork.
A few reviewers had negative experiences, citing poor customer service, feeling disrespected, and difficulty in getting answers to their questions.
4.2
Based on 48 reviews
Profile Website Phone
At Iron City Insurance, we are an Independent Insurance Agency that offers a range of insurance coverages to our clients in Florida, including Personal Auto, Homeowners, Individual Life, and Commercial insurance options. Our dedicated team will work with you to address all your insurance concerns and provide tailored solutions to meet your unique needs. With our online quick quotes system, you can easily compare rates and policies from our top insurance companies to find the best fit for you. Our services include quote requests, policy changes, and submissions for insurance coverage. By partnering with us, you can save money on your insurance premiums while receiving the coverage you need to protect your family or business. We are located in Sarasota, Florida, and serve the surrounding areas, including Bradenton, Lakewood Ranch, Longboat Key, Manatee, and Siesta Key.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
MGildarInsurance.com is an independent insurance agency providing comprehensive insurance solutions, including life insurance, Medicare, long-term care insurance, and annuities, to individuals and families across the United States. Our team is dedicated to delivering exceptional customer service and expert guidance to ensure our clients receive the best insurance options for their unique needs.
The reviewers praise Michael's professionalism, expertise, and excellent customer service, making him an excellent agent to work with.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
R. Webber Inc. is a family-owned business specializing in paver installation, removal, and hauling, as well as repair work, cleaning, and sealing of existing pavers. With over 30 years of experience, we provide quality services in driveways, pool decks, patios, and walkways, and offer eco-friendly paver options.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Sarasota Health and Financial Services, Inc. is a family-owned and operated independent life and health insurance agency, serving the Sarasota community since 1980, specializing in Individual Major Medical and Group Health Insurance, Medicare Supplements, Medicare Advantage Plans, Life Insurance, Annuities, and Long Term Care.
The reviewers praise the excellent customer service, personalized approach, and knowledgeable staff at Sarasota Health and Financial Services.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
GreatFlorida Insurance is a insurance agency that offers a wide range of insurance services, including auto, homeowners, boat, and commercial insurance. They have a team of local agents who can help you find the right insurance policy to suit your needs. With GreatFlorida Insurance, you can get a free quote, file a claim, or learn more about their insurance products and services. Their goal is to provide easy, low-cost, and worry-free insurance solutions to their customers. Whether you're looking for auto insurance in Florida, homeowners insurance, or boat insurance, GreatFlorida Insurance has got you covered.
Reviewers praised the excellent customer service, competitive rates, and hassle-free process.
One reviewer felt misled by the auto insurance quote they received, which was significantly higher than the direct quote from Progressive.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Shapiro Insurance Group is an independent insurance and financial services agency that provides a wide range of insurance products including home owners insurance, renters insurance, flood insurance, fire insurance, umbrella insurance, auto insurance, boat insurance, motorcycle insurance, RV insurance, ATV insurance, classic car insurance, business insurance, commercial liability insurance, commercial auto insurance, professional liability insurance, workers comp insurance, life insurance, term life insurance, whole life insurance, disability income insurance, health insurance, and dental insurance. Our friendly agents understand your dilemma and make it easy for you to shop rates from multiple carriers. We'll do all the work for you by providing quotes from several insurance companies, so you can make the most informed decisions. We are licensed in 18 states to provide insurance products from numerous insurance companies.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone