"Join the Family" - where every meal is a welcoming experience
John Anthony's Restaurant, a cherished establishment in Plum Borough, has been serving the community since 1985. Owned and operated by the D'Acierno family, this restaurant has become a staple for Italian cuisine and fresh seafood in the area. With a commitment to quality and service, John Anthony's has been providing a distinctive dining experience for families and individuals with discerning palates.
The D'Acierno family has always prioritized the total dining experience, from the moment customers walk in the door to the last bite of their meal. The servers are well-trained and eager to make every visit a satisfying one, while the chefs are dedicated to taste, consistency, originality, and promptness. With a focus on homemade soups, fresh salads, Italian greens and beans, hand-breaded appetizers, and unique entrees, the menu offers something for everyone.
Our Menu
John Anthony's Restaurant prides itself on its extensive menu, which features a variety of options for families and individuals. For those with a hearty appetite, the burgers are made with 1/2 lb of fresh, hand-formed ground beef, grilled over an open flame. The award-winning fish sandwich features fresh, breaded Icelandic Cod, while the hoagies are toasted and overstuffed. All of the Italian entrees are made to order with imported pasta and the freshest components.
The kids' menu offers healthy options including ravioli and chicken salads, ensuring that everyone in the family has something to enjoy. The spaghetti sauce is a particular point of pride for the restaurant, as it is a recipe passed down from Aunt Carol, who made the wedding soup, meatballs, and sauce for the first 30 years of the restaurant's history.
Catering & Banquets
John Anthony's Restaurant specializes in banquets of all sizes, from 25 to 100 people. With a newly remodeled dining room that boasts large windows, high ceilings, linen tablecloths (upon request), and attentive servers, the atmosphere is perfect for rehearsal dinners, wedding and baby showers, baptisms, birthdays, communions, retirements, anniversaries, and more. The restaurant offers fabulous buffet options at a variety of prices and selections, as well as funeral luncheons.
The catering menu offers a range of options for events and banquets, from appetizers and salads to pasta dishes and entrees. With a commitment to quality and service, John Anthony's Restaurant is dedicated to making every event a success.
Overall Experience
The reviews showcase a mix of positive and negative experiences at John Anthony's. While some reviewers rave about the food, service, and atmosphere, others express disappointment and frustration.
Food Quality
The food at John Anthony's is a highlight for many reviewers, with dishes like Chicken Parmesan, Fried Mushrooms, and Veal Parmesan receiving high praise. The portion sizes are deemed reasonable, and the prices are considered fair.
Service
The service at John Anthony's is generally excellent, with many reviewers complimenting the friendly and attentive wait staff. However, one reviewer expresses disappointment with the take-out order process, citing inflexibility and poor communication.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere at John Anthony's is a topic of contention. While some reviewers appreciate the cozy and welcoming ambiance, others are put off by the restaurant's political signage and stickers, which they find offensive and unwelcoming.
Political Controversy
A significant issue for some reviewers is the presence of political signage and stickers in the restaurant, which they find divisive and unwelcoming. This has led to some customers feeling uncomfortable and unwilling to return.
