Catering with love, one meal at a time
A Warm Welcome to Carmella's!
Carmella's Plates & Pints is a charming restaurant in the heart of Pittsburgh, where American comfort food meets an inviting atmosphere. Co-owners Carmella Salem and Michael Alberter have cultivated a space that celebrates delicious food, friendship, and unforgettable experiences.
From Comfort Food to Crafted Cocktails
Our menu offers a delightful blend of classic and innovative dishes, drawing inspiration from traditional American cuisine. From succulent comfort food to shareable plates, our talented chefs use fresh, seasonal ingredients to create mouthwatering experiences.
Pair your meal with one of our meticulously crafted cocktails from our extensive whiskey bar, featuring over 500 bourbons, scotches, and tequilas. We take pride in offering top-notch spirits and presentations.
Events and Adventures
Carmella's is the perfect place to gather for any occasion. Celebrate your next birthday, graduation, or special event in our cozy and welcoming space. We also host live music events, featuring Pittsburgh's finest musicians, creating a vibrant and energetic atmosphere.
An Experience for Everyone
Whether you're looking for a cozy dinner date, a night out with friends, or a memorable event, Carmella's Plates & Pints offers something for everyone. Our warm and welcoming staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring you have a memorable experience.
Join us at Carmella's Plates & Pints and discover a taste of quality food, vibrant atmosphere, and unforgettable memories!
Mixed Reviews
Food Quality
The reviewers generally praise the food quality, with many mentioning that the dishes are delicious and flavorful. Others have noted that the food is good, but not exceptional.
Service
The service is consistently praised, with many reviewers mentioning that the staff are friendly, attentive, and accommodating. A few reviewers have noted some issues with service, such as mistakes with orders.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere is widely praised, with reviewers appreciating the unique decor, cozy vibe, and historical images and memorabilia. However, a few reviewers have noted that the atmosphere can be a bit too fancy or lacking in cohesion.
Value
Some reviewers feel that the prices are a bit high, and that the value may not be worth the cost. Others have noted that the prices are average or reasonable.
Highlights and Lowlights
The highlights of the reviews include the unique atmosphere, delicious food, and friendly service. The lowlights include some issues with service, prices, and food pairings.
