Connect with Top-Rated Hotels in Cape May!

Read verified customer reviews of the most reliable hotels in Cape May, NJ. Save time and money by comparing prices, getting expert recommendations, and finding the perfect fit for your needs.

Find businesses near you
Lokal Hotel & Vacation Homes is a boutique luxury apartment hotel and vacation home brand that offers unparalleled design and comfort. With two apartment hotels in Philadelphia, a micro resort in Cape May, NJ, and two vacation cabins within an hour from Philly, we have something for everyone. Our properties are carefully curated to provide a unique and unforgettable experience for our guests. With amenities such as fully equipped kitchens, comfortable living spaces, and personalized service, we strive to exceed our guests' expectations.
The hotel received universal praise for its excellent amenities, cleanliness, and perfect location.
5.0
Based on 204 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Capitol Resorts is a family of boutique hotels, cottages, and restaurants located in Cape May, New Jersey, and the East End of Long Island, New York. Founded on the principles of authentic hospitality and a commitment to creating classic American resort experiences, we have been providing memorable experiences for over 30 years. Our properties, each with its own unique personality, share a common goal: to provide an authentic, all-American resort vacation.
Guests generally praised the hotel's luxurious rooms, friendly service, and excellent location.
Some guests mentioned minor issues with noise levels and limited dining options.
4.7
Based on 320 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Located in beautiful Cape May, the Sea Crest Inn is a beachfront hotel that offers romantic getaways for couples. Our hotel features luxury oceanfront suites with fully equipped kitchens, an outdoor whirlpool, and extra-large balconies. Enjoy stunning views of the Atlantic Ocean and convenient access to shopping, fine dining, and historic homes.
The Sea Crest Motel is praised for its cleanliness, comfortable rooms, excellent location, friendly staff, and great value.
A few reviewers mentioned minor issues with toilets, hot water, and bed sheets.
4.5
Based on 332 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Nestled in the heart of Cape May, NJ, Montreal Beach Resort offers luxurious accommodations, stunning ocean views, and top-notch amenities. Our 70 well-appointed rooms, including suites and efficiencies, feature private balconies with breathtaking views. Enjoy our oceanfront pool, rooftop bar, and award-winning Harry's Ocean Bar & Grille on site. Looking for a romantic getaway or a fun-filled family vacation? We have everything you need for an unforgettable stay. Book your dream seaside wedding or meeting with our dedicated event team. Come and experience the ultimate Cape May experience at Montreal Beach Resort!
The hotel's location, cleanliness, and amenities were praised by many guests.
Some guests had negative experiences with the front desk staff and the beds, citing poor communication and uncomfortable sleeping conditions.
4.4
Based on 515 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The Hotel Macomber is a family run Old Seashore historic hotel in Cape May, NJ, located just steps away from the beach. Built at the turn of the century, the Hotel Macomber was the last Historic Landmark building erected in Cape May and the largest frame structure for its time east of the Mississippi River! Freshly renovated, this grand shingle style mansion turned boutique hotel in Cape May, is within walking distance of all local attractions and across the street from activities at Convention Hall. The hotel is home to the award winning Union Park Restaurant, offers a Bagel time breakfast shop and Cape Island bike rental. The main floor of this boutique hotel includes a large living room and a bright solarium overlooking Beach Avenue, right in the heart of Cape May, NJ. Rockers on the ocean front verandas tempt you to linger and relax.
The hotel's great location, clean and cozy rooms, and friendly staff have made it a popular choice among guests.
Some guests have noted issues with the hotel's child-free policy, internet signal, and air conditioning units.
4.3
Based on 212 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The West Cape Motel is a picturesque retreat in Cape May, New Jersey, offering comfortable and modern accommodations with amenities like a pool, BBQ area, and kitchenettes in some rooms. Located near the Cape May bird sanctuary and Sunset Beach, our motel is perfect for nature lovers and beachgoers alike. Our rooms are newly renovated and come with amenities like flat-screen TVs, refrigerators, and more. We're just minutes from the Atlantic Ocean and offer a relaxing getaway for couples, families, and birders.
The West Cape Motel has received overwhelmingly positive reviews for its cleanliness, modern rooms, friendly staff, and quiet location, with many guests praising its value for the price.
Some guests have mentioned that the parking situation can be challenging, and one guest noted that their room had a smoke smell when they entered.
4.3
Based on 46 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The Cape Harbor Motor Inn is a family-run hotel offering 32 contemporary, spacious rooms in the heart of Cape May, NJ. Our hotel is centrally located near the harbor and the Coast Guard Base, making it an ideal choice for those attending Coast Guard bootcamp graduation. We take pride in the quality of our rooms and the cleanliness standards we maintain. Our friendly staff welcomes you to the hospitality of our hotel, where you can relax and enjoy the historic charm of Cape May.
The hotel's quiet and kid-friendly environment, excellent service, and great value make it an excellent choice for families and couples.
Some guests have reported issues with the hotel's maintenance, including dirty air conditioners and dusty surfaces.
4.2
Based on 172 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The Hotel Alcott is a masterfully restored Italianate-bracketed villa located steps from the Atlantic Ocean and Cape May's award-winning beach in Victorian Cape May, NJ. Here old meets new on a majestic scale. With 31 custom-furnished guest rooms and suites, the hotel offers the best of both worlds. Stay with us and experience the modern comfort and bygone elegance of Cape May's Hotel Alcott. Each of our guest rooms has a unique size or shape and varying architectural features, but each has everything you need to relax, unwind, and renew after a long day of exploring all that Cape May has to offer.
The hotel's friendly staff and convenient location were praised by some guests.
The hotel's overpricing, lack of amenities, poor parking, and COVID-19 safety concerns were major complaints among guests.
4.0
Based on 167 reviews
Profile Website Phone
The Chalfonte Hotel is a historic hotel located in Cape May, New Jersey, recognized as the oldest original hotel in Cape May, America's first seaside resort. The hotel offers a unique seashore experience defined by warm, Southern-style hospitality. It features cottage rentals, spacious suites, guest rooms with premium and European style baths, and traditional rooms with shared baths down the hall. With a rich history dating back to 1876, the Chalfonte Hotel has been a beloved destination for generations of travelers.
The Chalfonte Hotel's beautiful location, charming atmosphere, excellent food, and friendly staff make it a standout hotel in Cape May.
Some reviewers noted issues with the hotel's maintenance, including issues with beds, towels, and pillows.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
The Jersey Cape Motel is a family-owned business located in Cape May, New Jersey, offering a quiet and friendly atmosphere with clean, comfortable, and affordable rooms. We're close to Cape May beaches, great restaurants, local marinas, the Cape May - Lewes Ferry, birding areas, and many local historical sites. All 29 rooms are first floor and non-smoking, with free WiFi and plenty of parking available. Whether you're here to relax, fish, golf, go birding, on business, or to take the Ferry to Delaware, the Jersey Cape Motel is your home away from home.
Many reviewers praised the motel's cleanliness, friendly staff, and convenient location, and several reported having excellent experiences.
One reviewer reported a negative experience with a member of the housekeeping staff, and another mentioned the motel's poor wi-fi and cell coverage.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
The Blue Fish Inn is a cozy hotel located in Cape May, New Jersey, offering comfortable and affordable rooms with a range of amenities, including pet-friendly options. Our hotel features 12 ground-level units, with 4 rooms designed for dog-friendly stays. With a convenient location just 6 blocks from the beach, we provide a serene and relaxing stay for our guests. Our hotel prides itself on exceptional service, cleanliness, and hospitality. Whether you're looking for a romantic getaway or a family vacation, we have the perfect room for you.
The reviews praised the hotel's cleanliness, amenities, customer service, and location, with many reviewers expressing their intent to return.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone