Connect with Top-Rated Insurance Agents in Tallahassee!

Read verified customer reviews of the most reliable insurance agents in Tallahassee, FL. Save time and money by comparing prices, getting expert recommendations, and finding the perfect fit for your needs.

Find businesses near you
Premier Insurance Agency Inc. is a full-service independent insurance agency providing a wide range of insurance services, including automobile, business, homeowners, life, motorcycle, recreational vehicle, renters, trucking, watercraft, and windstorm insurance to individuals and businesses in Tallahassee, Florida, and surrounding areas.
Shanna Pohlmann's clients praise her exceptional service, expertise, and dedication to finding the best insurance plans for their specific needs.
5.0
Based on 55 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Pichard Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency serving Tallahassee, FL, and the surrounding counties of Gadsden, Jefferson, Leon, and Wakulla since 1970. As an independent insurance agency, we represent different insurance companies, enabling you to compare coverage options and prices before buying. Whether you are shopping for home insurance, car insurance, business insurance, church insurance, or a package of insurance policies, we can help find the right policy for you. Our services include auto insurance, commercial insurance, church insurance, and more. We also provide client resources, reviews, and news. Our experienced staff works to advise you regarding the best policy that fits your needs, offering personalized service and guidance.
The reviewers praise Pichard Insurance Agency for their exceptional customer service, professionalism, and personalized approach.
5.0
Based on 8 reviews
Profile Website Phone
As a dedicated State Farm Insurance Agent, I'm committed to providing excellent service and personalized quotes for auto, home, renters, and life insurance in Tallahassee and all of Florida. My team and I strive for excellence every day, with over 26 years of experience with the company. With convenient office hours Monday to Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM, and evenings and Saturdays by appointment, we're always available to serve. We're centrally located in Tallahassee, close to the old Tallahassee Mall now known as The Centre of Tallahassee.
The reviewers praised the exceptional service, professionalism, and personalized attention from the staff at Bill Reardon State Farm Insurance.
The only negative review complained about misquoting, unprofessionalism, and greed from the agency.
4.9
Based on 306 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Kingdom Tree Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency offering a wide range of personal and business insurance solutions, including home, auto, umbrella, business auto, general liability, errors and omissions liability, and more. With a commitment to personalized service and expertise, the agency helps clients find the best possible insurance coverage for their unique needs.
The majority of the reviewers have had a positive experience with Kingdom Tree Insurance Group, praising the company's quick response to their queries, competitive quotes, and professional staff.
4.9
Based on 58 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Smallridge Insurance and Financial Services, Inc. is a full-service insurance agency providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals and businesses in the Tallahassee, FL area. We offer a wide range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, and recreational vehicles insurance. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to providing exceptional service and guidance to help our clients achieve their insurance goals.
Clients praise agents for their exceptional customer service, expertise, and personalized solutions, leading to satisfactory experiences and recommendations.
4.8
Based on 183 reviews
Profile Website Phone
McKee Insurance Agency is a full-service insurance agency that offers a wide range of insurance products to individuals and businesses throughout Florida. With over 40 years of experience, we provide top-class service, expert guidance, and competitive insurance rates. Our insurance products include auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, life insurance, and recreational vehicle insurance.
Agents at McKee Insurance Agency received high praise for their knowledge, honesty, and responsiveness, saving customers money and providing excellent service.
Some reviewers experienced issues with rate increases and poor customer service from specific agents.
4.8
Based on 45 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Fuqua Insurance Agency is a family-owned and operated business that has been serving the State of Florida for 45 years, providing personalized insurance services, including auto, home, commercial, life, and more, with a commitment to exceptional customer service and competitive rates.
Customers praise the agency for its excellent customer service, competitive rates, and personalized experience.
4.8
Based on 42 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Chancy Insurance Inc. is a full-service independent insurance agency serving Florida and Georgia, providing exceptional insurance options for both personal and commercial purposes, with a reputation for quality insurance products and exceptional customer service.
Exceptional customer service, personalized support, and tailored insurance solutions earned Chancy Insurance high praise from satisfied clients.
One reviewer had a negative experience with the owner, citing arrogance and a lack of responsiveness to their questions.
4.7
Based on 19 reviews
Profile Website Phone
As a trusted insurance agent in Tallahassee, FL, I provide personalized insurance solutions to individuals, families, and businesses. With over 15 years of experience, I focus on providing free quotes for life, auto, renter, health, and homeowners insurance. My goal is to help you make informed decisions about your insurance needs, ensuring you have the right coverage at the right price. I proudly serve all of Florida, offering a range of insurance products and exceptional customer service.
The customer service and agent performance were frequently praised for being helpful, understanding, and knowledgeable.
Some reviewers experienced communication breakdowns and policy issues, including unaddressed emails and policy terminations due to mistakes.
4.5
Based on 16 reviews
Profile Website Phone
At Affiliated Insurance Agencies of Florida Inc., we offer complete insurance policies for families and individuals throughout the Tallahassee area. We pride ourselves on providing personalized service and working closely with our clients to determine individual plans that suit their unique needs. Our services include auto insurance, homeowners insurance, recreational insurance, life insurance, and more. With decades of experience, our agents are dedicated to finding the perfect coverage plan for you. Whether you're looking to protect your vehicle, home, investments, or loved ones, we're here to help.
The agency received praise for its professionalism, customer service, and knowledgeable staff.
The agency was criticized for delayed responses, outrageous quotes, unprofessional behavior, and inconsistent information, as well as alleged scam-like behavior.
4.3
Based on 22 reviews
Profile Website Phone
State Farm Insurance Agent Dick Franklin is a trusted and reliable insurance agency in Tallahassee, FL, offering a wide range of insurance products and services, including auto, home, life, health, and business insurance, to individuals, families, and businesses in the community.
Excellent customer service, knowledgeable agents, and personalized recommendations.
Frustration with rate increases, poor communication, and inconsistent information.
4.1
Based on 43 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Jerrell Lowery Ins Agcy Inc is a State Farm Insurance agency offering a wide range of insurance products and services, including Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, and Rec Vehicles insurance, as well as banking services and other financial products. Our experienced team works with clients to understand their specific needs and provide personalized solutions to ensure they have the right coverage.
Exceptional customer service, excellent pricing, and a helpful team make for a positive experience.
Poor roadside assistance, incompetent service, and unprofessional behavior lead to frustration and disappointment.
4.1
Based on 15 reviews
Profile Website Phone
Legacy Insurance Solutions is a full-service insurance agency serving the Florida community with offices in Tallahassee and Palm Beach, offering personalized coverage options for individuals, families, and businesses, including auto policies, boats and marine insurance, homeowner's insurance, life and health plans, high net worth programs, commercial property insurance, casualty insurance, management liability, workers' compensation, employee group benefits, and retirement plans.
One reviewer had a positive experience with the company, praising their knowledge and trustworthiness.
Multiple reviewers have alleged scams and had poor customer service experiences.
2.6
Based on 5 reviews
Profile Website Phone
State Farm Insurance Agent Gayla Parks provides a range of insurance products and services, including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, and pet insurance, as well as banking, mutual funds, and annuities. With over 20 years of experience, Gayla Parks and her team offer personalized quotes, policy reviews, and claims support to individuals and businesses in Tallahassee, FL. They are dedicated to helping clients prepare for hurricane season and other life events, and providing expert guidance to ensure they have the right coverage for their needs.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
The Nate DeGraaf State Farm Agency is a leading insurance agency in Tallahassee, Florida, offering a wide range of insurance products including auto, homeowners, condo, renters, business, life, health, pet, and other products. With over 22 years of experience, our agency is dedicated to educating, servicing, and protecting our customers. We are proud to have earned the coveted Chairman Circle Award in 2023 and are committed to providing exceptional service to our customers. Our agency is proud to serve the entire state of Florida, helping our customers navigate the complexities of insurance and provide peace of mind in the event of unexpected events. Whether it's renters' insurance or business insurance, we have the expertise and resources to help you find the right coverage for your needs.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Andrew Jackson Insurance, LLC is a professional liability insurance agency providing medical malpractice insurance quotes online for physicians, surgeons, dentists, and podiatrists. Our experienced team offers personalized insurance services, connecting clients with top providers in the industry. We provide a range of coverage options, including auto and health insurance, to ensure clients receive the right coverage for their needs. Our company prides itself on finding the perfect policies for our clients and is available to address any concerns, 24/7.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
P Catsimpiris Ins Agency Inc, led by experienced insurance agent Peter Catsimpiris, offers a wide range of insurance products including auto, motorcycle, homeowners, condo, renters, personal articles, business, life, health, and rec vehicles. With a strong commitment to customer satisfaction and a focus on personalized service, the agency helps clients navigate their insurance needs efficiently. With a rating of 4.8 out of 5 on Google and numerous positive reviews, P Catsimpiris Ins Agency Inc is dedicated to providing top-notch insurance solutions and exceptional customer service.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Providing custom solutions for nearly all your insurance needs, Demont Insurance was founded in 1964 to bring quality and value to our clients. We believe in order to help protect the best things in life, you must work with a top insurance agent that listens to you. That's why our Florida insurance agency is dedicated to equipping our clients with the tools and resources needed to dream it, do it, and defend it with Demont. Our team of experts provides a wide range of insurance products and services, including general liability, commercial property, commercial auto, management liability, worker's compensation, bonds, employee benefits, life insurance, automobile insurance, flood insurance, homeowners insurance, rental properties insurance, umbrella insurance, and powersports insurance. With access to a multitude of carriers, we can provide options that fit your unique needs. Our goal is to help you reduce risk, gain stability, and protect what matters most.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Thielen Plus Insurance & Financial Services offers a wide range of insurance and financial services to individuals and businesses in Florida. Their expert team, led by Agency Principal Adam Thielen, provides personalized insurance planning and risk management solutions. With over 40 years of experience, they help clients protect their assets and achieve their financial goals. They offer insurance products such as auto, home, commercial, and life insurance, as well as financial services like retirement planning and investment management.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Waterhouse Insurance & Financial Services specializes in auto insurance in Tallahassee, providing superior insurance coverage and customer service at low rates. We offer a wide range of insurance services including auto, home, business, and life insurance, tailored to meet the needs of individuals, families, and businesses throughout Tallahassee and Florida.
Many customers praised the helpful and prompt service they received from specific agents.
Some customers expressed frustration with customer service, citing issues with responsiveness, communication, and professionalism.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
As a seasoned State Farm insurance agent with 33 years of experience, I provide personalized insurance solutions to individuals and families in Tallahassee, FL. My expertise ranges from auto, home, and life insurance to business, health, and pet insurance. I take pride in staying up-to-date with the latest industry knowledge and trends, holding prestigious designations such as ChFC, CLU, and CASL. My goal is to help you navigate the complex world of insurance and provide you with tailored options to protect what matters most to you. Whether you're a new customer or a long-time friend, I am committed to delivering exceptional service and guiding you towards a secure and prosperous future.
The reviews praise the exceptional customer service, staff expertise, and competitive rates provided by the Dave Williams State Farm office.
One reviewer experienced issues with State Farm corporate's system and automated charges, but their local agent was able to resolve the issues.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone
Michael Frantz Ins Agency Inc offers a wide range of insurance products including Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet, and Banking services. With over 35 years of experience, our team focuses on relocation to the Tallahassee market and provides free quotes on Auto Insurance and Home Insurance.
N/A
Not rated yet
Profile Website Phone